Friday, April 1, 2016

Part of life

During Dad’s illness, people frequently asked us how the boys were doing. I think people were concerned that it would be very frightening for kids to be near someone who is dying. This was not our experience. There’s no question that it was sad, for them and for all of us, but it would have been sad no matter where Dad was. 


We were completely honest with the boys about Dad’s condition, starting with the day he was diagnosed. They knew all along that he was dying. But most of the time he was not dying imminently, and they just enjoyed his company in the ways that were available. As he got sicker there were fewer and fewer things that they could do together. But they could watch Warriors games with him, and give him hugs, and tell him their rose and thorn for the day. They knew that their hugs were a special kind of essential medicine that only they could provide. Aaron said, “The medicine that he gets from the doctors and nurses helps with his body, and my hugs are to help heal his soul.” Absolutely right, darling. 


Dale and I were open about our sadness. When I was overwhelmed by my emotions I just went ahead and cried. This made the boys nervous, especially Aaron; but it helped a lot when I explained what I like people to do when I am sad. I said I like people to just be with me, and not change the subject, and maybe give me a hug or a little pat. I said I didn’t want to be cheered up, because when I have big sad feelings I need to just feel them. I called it a “sad attack.” I explained that when I have a sad attack, I will cry for a little while, and then it will pass and I will feel okay again. Once I said what I wanted, both boys carried out my wishes to a T, which was very comforting for me (and I think helped them, too). 


Sometimes Aaron was overwhelmed by sadness, and Jordan less frequently. How not? But after a streak of sadness they would go back to their normal selves. Their teachers, who all knew what was going on, reported that they were fine at school. When we talked to them about Dad’s condition we used nontechnical language, which was better for all of us. They were fascinated by all the science stuff, especially the IV nutrition, which was a complex daily medical ritual involving a lot of interesting gear. They were friendly with all the visiting nurses, and thanked them profusely for their care. When there was something going on that they didn’t want to be close to, they just went to their room and played together. They slept through the toughest stuff – Dad’s worst pain and waking nightmares were in the wee hours, and their room was far enough away that they were not disturbed. Their routines were disrupted because Dale and I were often busy taking care of Dad, and that was a drag for them. But they understood, and managed well enough.

Dad died in our home. Aaron did not want to see his body, which of course is perfectly fine. Jordan, however, wanted to say goodbye, so we sat together in Dad’s familiar bedroom, observing that his body was still and pale and peaceful. Jordan said, “It looks emptier.” After a few minutes, he was ready to leave.

It is easy for me to imagine circumstances that other families could be in that would be traumatizing, for the children and for everyone. In our case, we were sad together, because it is so sad that Grandpa is not with us anymore; but we were not traumatized. We knew we had taken the best care of him that any family possibly could take of their beloved grandpa. We gave him every kind of dignity we knew how to give. We could not keep the cancer away, and he died of it. It is a difficult truth that everything that lives, eventually dies. Our hope is for the kids to experience death as a part of life; heartbreaking, and also the inevitable end of every person’s story.

Coloring

Life with Dad involved many doctor appointments, regular trips to urgent care, and several days in the hospital. I was with him almost all the time. Fortunately, a perceptive friend had given me a beautiful grownup coloring book for my birthday, and this turned out to be the perfect way to while away all that medical downtime with my dad. It took just the tiniest bit of cognition, enough to occupy my mind but not enough to really require anything of me. It was a great conversation piece with all the doctors and nurses. And it engaged me in making something lovely.



Now I’m back to reading books, which I think is a sign that I have more cognition available. (When I tried to read in the hospital I just read the same sentence over and over.) But I really appreciated the coloring when I needed it.

Dad in March

In the seventh week, Dad finally had a feeding tube placed. However, feeding him through it didn’t work: his digestive system was not functioning enough to take the food. In the middle of that week he was overcome with pain unlike anything he had experienced before and went into the hospital. He had multiple dramatic events, including atrial fibrillation. The hospital did a few days of detective work to try and sort out what had caused the emergency pain, but didn’t find anything that they could treat. He was unconscious a lot, his pain was difficult to control, and when he was awake he was delirious, paranoid, and agitated.

In the eighth week, he again rallied from that low point. When we brought him home on Monday, March 7, he was lucid and comfortable: still very weak (barely ambulatory), but able to enjoy our company and the early signs of spring through the living room window. During the day we had precious conversations about what he wanted and did not want, medically. The nights, however, were very hard, with a lot of pain and waking nightmares.

After just a few days, he didn’t wake up anymore. He was at peace when he died, and I was with him.

Dad in February

The third and fourth weeks that Dad was here, he had radiation treatment every day. And he got more and more weak and tired. He was still able to get around the house on his own, but other than the radiation treatments, he just stayed home. He didn’t read or putter on his laptop. He didn’t talk much. He napped a lot. Sometimes he talked on the phone to friends. He was nauseous and in pain, and his medication options were limited by his inability to swallow; we used dissolvable zofran and concentrated oral morphine. He was cold most of the time, so he sat by the fire and dozed.



His fatigue may have been a side effect of the radiation, or the morphine, or a symptom of malnutrition, or cancer – or all of the above. I stopped feeling comfortable leaving him alone for more than maybe an hour, because he was so weak. I sat with him, and did stuff around the house, and did the work of managing his care. Every day was structured by medical events: the radiation treatment, the IV nutrition, nurses visiting to check up on things, equipment being delivered.


We had a ramp built in front of the house. It seemed obvious that he would need it.


On Friday of the fourth week, he had a drastically bad day, involving not only radiation treatment but also a bone scan and some terrible traffic on I-5. He missed his regular dose of pain meds and became extremely exhausted. When he finally got home, he got into bed, and barely woke up for days. His vital signs were poor (low blood pressure, low blood oxygen, rapid pulse, shallow breathing). The visiting nurse warned us that he might be near the end. At some point when he was awake, I told him what the nurse had said, and he asked me to send an email to his friends to come and visit him. They did, and in the fifth week nine beloved friends came to see him. He rallied, and was able to enjoy his visits with every one of them. It felt like a triumph.



Those who could not visit sent letters and video messages, and we read or played these aloud to him. This was awesome; he was very touched, and we all got to learn more about what he had meant to people. Also during this week, his throat got better: he could swallow his own secretions and no longer suffered from nausea. However, he was still very weak and very disabled, needing a lot of physical assistance to do anything, and a lot of active pain management.

In the sixth week, we hired home health aides to take care of Dad 40 hours a week (during weekdays), to relieve me from much of the physical care that I had been doing. They were wonderful with Dad, and I was so grateful for their help. Dad accepted their care, and tried to get a little stronger by doing things like getting out of bed for a little while each day. His throat continued to be better, and he was even able to drink a little water. He was still receiving IV nutrition around the clock, so the drinking was recreational. But it gave him tremendous pleasure. No one can appreciate a sip of cold ice water like a person who thought they would never have one again.

He remained extremely weak and disabled. Getting out of bed was an achievement. His pain was significantly worse, and we were always chasing it. To some extent this is just how it is with cancer, and with opiates – the pain is a moving target (in his case mostly due to his bones crumbling), and the body adapts to the morphine. Nonetheless it was very stressful and worrisome. The goal is to keep the person both comfortable and awake, and it is an elusive goal. By then he had not been out of the house for weeks (since the end of the radiation treatment), and only got out of bed once or twice a day.

During this period Dad lost his sense of time: he would wake up with no feeling for whether it was day or night, Tuesday or Saturday. To be fair, the life of an invalid is not so different from one day to the next, and he was sleeping off and on without regard to the time of day. But my dad was a man who kept meticulous daily routines and a detailed calendar, and the disorientation was very distressing for him. He always wanted to know what time it was, what day it was, whether he had any appointments that day, who was coming to the house, whether there were any visits from friends in the future. He was always looking for his phone, even though he had lost the dexterity to manipulate it and couldn’t read the screen anymore. Eventually we hung a large-print calendar by his bed and wrote his appointments on it. This was very reassuring to him, and useful for all of us.


During this same period Dad had a lot of very weird dreams that felt very real to him. When he was awake, he mostly understood that they could not have actually happened, but not always. Sometimes he dreamt that he didn’t have cancer, but it always turned out that he did. Once he dreamt that there was a giant bar fight and he was “perched in the rafters with his Group Health gun” (Group Health was his HMO). Many of his dreams were violent or threatening, involving war scenes or international espionage. As the weeks went on, his dreams intruded more on his waking life. Once he wanted me to arrange a meeting with the secretary of state because he thought he was going to be kidnapped by the Russians, who secretly had a cure for esophageal cancer; they were going to take him hostage to demonstrate the cure, and demand payment that would compromise national security. One night when Dale was taking care of him he understood himself to be in a bad restaurant, one with very poor service. “Aren’t there any servers in this place?” he complained. “Can’t we just get a cab and get out of here?” Dale, who was providing the best service possible under the circumstances, said “Man, I really wish we could.”

Dad in January

Dad was diagnosed with metastatic esophageal cancer on December 30, after a months-long period of increasingly severe gastric reflux. He spent two weeks closing up his affairs and saying his goodbyes, then flew up to Seattle to live with us. He was comfortable and mobile and very much himself; it was no problem for him to do things on his own. His main symptom was difficulty eating or drinking.

The first week he was here we visited five oncologists to try and form a treatment plan: two medical oncologists (those are the chemo doctors), two radiation oncologists, and one surgeon. Each of them suggested a different course of treatment. The only unanimity was that surgery would not be any use, because the cancer was too widespread (not only deep into the tissue of his esophagus, but also in his bones, liver, and lymph nodes). We came to realize that for Dad there was really no right answer, or put another way, no wrong answer. The argument for radiation treatment was that it would be short, localized to the major problem area, and not hard on your whole body at once the way chemo is. The argument for chemo was that it treats all the cancer everywhere in the body. The side effects of either were expected to be manageable.

Dad liked the radiation plan better and we would have started the radiation treatment right away, but in that same first week (four days after he arrived here), Dad’s throat closed completely so that he could not swallow anything at all. This was both uncomfortable (he couldn’t swallow his own saliva and needed to retch it up often) and urgently dangerous (he had no way to take in fluids or nutrition). We scheduled a feeding tube insertion for the following week, and brought him to urgent care every other day to get fluids and sometimes glucose. What with the oncologist consultations and the urgent care visits, I did a lot of coloring.

At the beginning of the second week that Dad was here, he was supposed to have the feeding tube inserted, but unfortunately his throat was closed so completely they couldn’t do the procedure (it normally involves snaking a 1-mm endoscope down your throat). They checked him into the hospital, expecting to insert the feeding tube with a different and more invasive surgical procedure. The boys came and made come-home-soon signs, and played chess.



Instead of the anticipated surgery, we wound up choosing for Dad to get IV nutrition at home. At the end of that week he started the IV nutrition, and started having nurses visit him at home almost every day to monitor his various medical needs.

During this period Dad’s primary reaction to his illness was bewilderment. He could hardly believe how sick he was – he had been taking good care of himself and monitoring his health actively for many years, including regular doctor visits and blood tests, and yet there was no warning of this extreme condition. He was also bewildered (and annoyed) by the uncertainty of his situation: no one could tell him how long he had, or what symptoms he was likely to develop, or what exactly a particular treatment would accomplish if anything. But we traipsed together to all of his doctor appointments, and weighed his options, and made the best decisions we could.

Burial

About five years ago Dad arranged to be buried at the veterans’ cemetery nearest us, Tahoma National Cemetery. He appreciated that burial is a veterans’ benefit (he was passionately opposed to burial expenses) and he wanted his gravesite to be convenient for us to visit. (Mom was cremated and her remains are in various places, some in my garden.) He arranged all of this in advance, and gave us all the information and documents we would need to carry out his arrangements, which basically consisted of the name of the cemetery and his discharge papers. It was very simple. I wish I had realized in advance that we would also need mortuary services; I had to figure that out the day he died. But I managed it.

This National Cemetery conducts burials with a brief military service. Pallbearers (some military, some family) conveyed the flag-draped casket from the hearse to the front of a shelter in the cemetery. Patriotic words were said, there was a three-volley fire, and taps was played. There was a beautiful ceremony for folding the flag and presenting it to me.

Then the military people left (with the casket), and the rest of us stayed in the shelter for our family service. About twenty of our friends and family were there with us, which was very meaningful to me. (It was a long way to drive, and in the middle of a weekday!) Alan spoke, and I spoke, and Dale spoke. The boys had intended to speak but were too overwhelmed in the moment, which is fine. We said kaddish. It was beautiful and meaningful.

The one part of the ceremony that was a little rough around the edges was that we wanted to put dirt into the grave, and the National Cemetery does not officially allow this. So we figured out where the gravesite was, and drove over there, and surprised the workers who were doing the actual burial. They didn’t argue with us, and we were able to fulfill our ritual.

We opened our home for three days of condolence calls (shiva), and were extremely touched by having people gather around us like that. Some were friends whose support had been crucial to us all along; some were community members who just wanted to show that they cared; some brought food, cards, and donations to Dad’s preferred charities. It was meaningful and heartening to have people fill our house (and our fridge) in this way. I am grateful for it.

Stephen J. Scherr

[This is the eulogy I read in Seattle at Dad’s burial, and then again at the gatherings in our home.]

Thank you all so much for being here today to honor and remember my father, Stephen Joseph Scherr. He was born in 1940 in Washington DC and grew up in Baltimore. After two years of college and military service, in 1965 he moved to San Francisco, joining his sister Judith and his parents who had moved there a few years before. He married my mother Jean in 1969. They wore paisley pantsuits in a little cottage on Telegraph Hill and I have the pictures to prove it. He was not a hippie, he was a “hippie sympathizer,” in his words (a joke I only got recently). I was born in 1971, and soon after that my parents moved to the Richmond District of San Francisco, where I grew up, and where my father lived until he moved in with us two months ago.

My father graduated from San Francisco Law School in 1972 and spent decades in solo practice as a criminal defense attorney. Most of his clients were ordinary people in difficult circumstances. He also represented politicians, police officers, homeless people, millionaires, priests, and college professors (including one of his own law school professors). His clients included an abused teenager who was taught to abuse younger children, a madam who was sentenced to serve time in a nunnery, a nun who beat her mother to death with a crucifix in an attempted exorcism, and the man who shot the mayor of San Francisco and the first openly gay supervisor (for which the defense is widely misunderstood, so please ask me about it). My grandmother was terribly distressed by my father’s clients, and did not see how he could stomach defending them. But my father believed that for the American judicial system to work, everyone needs the best representation they can receive. He loved representing the underdog, being the underdog, helping to keep the system honest. He had a lifelong commitment against the death penalty, and was glad to be able to say that none of his clients ever was sentenced to death.

Everyone who knew my father knew him to be reliable. This might make him sound boring, and to be honest he was extremely predictable: he wore the same clothes for decades, ate the same foods, wore the same style glasses, drove the same car. More importantly, though, he was reliable in the sense that he kept commitments he made to other people. He generously invited people to rely on him, and then used his knowledge and resources to do what he said he would do. Whether showing up at the agreed time and place, supporting me through college, mentoring a junior colleague, or defending the accused, everyone knew that he would be there and live up to his word. He was solid.

As a father he was witty, kind, and secure in our relationship. He respected me intellectually and admired my decision-making, teaching me to first do my research and then trust my instincts. He saw the best in me, and helped me recognize that even in difficult situations there is much to be grateful for. I see this positive outlook in our children, and hope it will be his legacy to them, along with a strong sense of justice, and a commitment to helping individual people who need it.

Now we are in another difficult situation, and as painful as it is, again there is much to be grateful for. My father lived long enough to have close relationships with Jordan and Aaron. During his illness we were able to bring him to live with us and take the best possible care of him. As a family we have given each other every kind of love and support and emotional safety that a family can give; and we are surrounded by a caring community that holds us up while we are bewildered, tired, and sad. I will miss my dad more than I can say. But I am thankful that his life story ends with dignity and family love.