[This is the eulogy I read at Dad's memorial in SF. It is about half the same as my Seattle eulogy.]
Thank you all so much for being here today to honor and remember my father, Stephen Joseph Scherr. He was born in 1940 in Washington DC and grew up in Baltimore. After two years of college and military service, in 1965 he moved here, to San Francisco, joining his sister Jes and his parents who had moved here a few years before. He married my mother Jean in 1969. They wore paisley pants in a little cottage on Telegraph Hill and I have the pictures to prove it. He was not a hippie, he was a “hippie sympathizer,” in his words (a joke I only got recently). I was born in 1971, and soon after that my parents moved to the Richmond District, where I grew up, and where my father lived until he moved in with us in January, just after his diagnosis.
He loved San Francisco. Once when I was admiring a view of the Golden Gate Bridge he said, “Your mother and I had the good taste to raise you in one of the most beautiful cities in the world.” They raised me to enjoy the advantages of living here: thanks to them I spent my childhood in Golden Gate Park, my adolescence walking from one side of the city to the other with my friends (because they wisely declined to let me drive the car), and much of high school at the Exploratorium, which eventually shaped my career in physics.
I was very aware of my father’s professional life and very much inspired by it. As most of you know, he defended some clients that non-lawyers might find distressing. My grandmother (his mother) did not see how he could stomach representing them. But I learned from him that for the American judicial system to work, everyone needs the best representation they can receive. I saw that he loved representing the underdog, being the underdog, helping to keep the system honest. I learned that ideally, the legal system protects us all from our own knee-jerk condemnations in favor of a more deliberate, more rational process – a perspective that serves me well in the sciences. My father was well aware that the system is flawed; his lifelong opposition to the death penalty was based in his knowledge that the system is racist, among other problems. But on the whole he respected social systems, and set an example of working to help us all live up to our ideals. He also set an example to me as someone who loved his work: he was grateful to have a job he enjoyed and was good at, and to have the opportunity to help individual people who needed it.
Everyone who knew my father knew him to be reliable. This might make him sound boring, and to be honest he was extremely predictable: he wore the same clothes for decades, ate the same foods, wore the same style glasses, drove the same car. More importantly, though, he was reliable in the sense that he kept commitments he made to other people. He generously invited people to rely on him, and then used his knowledge and resources to do what he said he would do. Whether showing up at the agreed time and place, supporting me through college, mentoring a junior colleague, or defending the accused, everyone knew that he would be there and live up to his word. He was solid.
His final illness was bewildering to him. It was completely unexpected, and its progress was so rapid. Every week brought new symptoms, new procedures. We never adjusted. But we were side by side every step of the way. During his illness we were able to bring him to live with us and take the best possible care of him. He and I made every decision together and were constant companions for his last two months, along with my husband Dale and our two kids, Jordan and Aaron, ages 11 and 8. Along with his sister Jes and sister-in-law Deena, we gave each other every kind of love and support and emotional safety that a family can give. You all helped too: some of you came to visit, and many others sent toasts, which we read aloud to him among family, laughing and crying and learning what he has meant to people. I will miss my father more than I can say; but I am grateful to have spent those last few weeks close to him, adding to a lifetime of warm memories.
Thank you all again so much for being here.
Thursday, April 14, 2016
Wednesday, April 13, 2016
Memorial
We held a memorial for Dad in San Francisco, because he lived there for fifty years and had an extensive community of many dear longtime friends and colleagues. We held it at the same place he had chosen for my mother’s memorial: the Golden Gate Club, a beautiful old building in the Presidio, overlooking the bay.
Dale prepared this beautiful welcome sign, along with an incredible slideshow of pictures spanning Dad’s entire life, which played silently throughout the event.
About 100 people attended, including his beloved buddies from the law office on Webster Street, old friends from his first days in San Francisco, the author of a book about Dad’s most famous trial, and many admirers from the Hall of Justice, including lawyers, judges, and detectives.
Another bunch of attendees were dear friends of my aunt's. One said, "I've never attended an event before that was half lawyers and half lesbians," which was pretty funny. Another took all these great photos, for which we are very thankful.
Here is my dear friend Rebekah, who helped Dad (and me) so much throughout Dad’s illness, talking to Mike Weiss, author of Double Play. Rebekah and I have now seen each other through the deaths of all four of our parents.
It was really a beautiful afternoon. It was a gift to me to receive condolences from so many people who loved and respected my father, some of whom are as close to me as uncles and aunts, and some of whom I had never met. It also felt good to give all of these people the opportunity to remember and mourn him together. They loved him, and they needed a chance to embrace each other in loss. Several people spoke from prepared remarks, some of which I will share in other posts.
Dale prepared this beautiful welcome sign, along with an incredible slideshow of pictures spanning Dad’s entire life, which played silently throughout the event.
About 100 people attended, including his beloved buddies from the law office on Webster Street, old friends from his first days in San Francisco, the author of a book about Dad’s most famous trial, and many admirers from the Hall of Justice, including lawyers, judges, and detectives.
Another bunch of attendees were dear friends of my aunt's. One said, "I've never attended an event before that was half lawyers and half lesbians," which was pretty funny. Another took all these great photos, for which we are very thankful.
Here is my dear friend Rebekah, who helped Dad (and me) so much throughout Dad’s illness, talking to Mike Weiss, author of Double Play. Rebekah and I have now seen each other through the deaths of all four of our parents.
It was really a beautiful afternoon. It was a gift to me to receive condolences from so many people who loved and respected my father, some of whom are as close to me as uncles and aunts, and some of whom I had never met. It also felt good to give all of these people the opportunity to remember and mourn him together. They loved him, and they needed a chance to embrace each other in loss. Several people spoke from prepared remarks, some of which I will share in other posts.
Friday, April 1, 2016
Estate business
My father’s affairs were simple and orderly. His estate has four items: a checking account, a savings account, an IRA, and a loan to us for the house that we live in. I know everything about all of these items (including account numbers and passwords) and have access to every piece of documentation, current and historical, because my dad was a perfect archivist. I am the executor and the sole beneficiary, and no one is going to contest anything. The business of his estate could not possibly be easier.
Even so it’s not very easy. To start, I went down to the bank where he had his checking account with the will and the death certificate, expecting them to transfer his funds to my account. Nope. Did you know that a person’s will is not the kind of legal document honored by a bank? I did not. Turns out the will is an expression of the deceased’s wish that I be the executor and beneficiary; it takes a court to establish that as a reality. The bank was not able to tell me exactly what documents they need, other than “court documents”; that was up to me to figure out.
With some online research I was able to determine that I needed a “letter testamentary,” and I also found instructions for how to do this without a lawyer. The actual experience down at the King County Superior Court was Brazil-like in its absurd bureaucracy: various documents with long names had to be filed and stamped and notarized and signed and copied, all in a very specific order, on two different floors of the courthouse, some with this clerk, some with that clerk, and some with the judge. There were specific associated rituals – for example, the clerk stamps these, but you stamp these yourself, using the clerk’s stamp. Why? Who knows. Stamp stamp. It all went pretty smoothly except that the will did not appear to some people to be original: it looked to them like a “very good Xerox.” I said it was original. They looked askance. I waited. The clerk ran her fingers over the signatures and said, “We’ll see what the judge says.” The judge looked at me over his glasses and said it looked like a copy. I said again that it was an original. He asked me if I had any siblings, or if my father had a life partner at the time of his death. I said no. He signed the order, and I took it back to the clerk, who said, “The judge accepted this will?” Yes he did. Thus I obtained my letter testamentary, stating that I am the executor. What about my being the sole beneficiary? Apparently that is not the court’s business – that’s just up to the executor, to dispose of the assets properly. I would never have been able to predict which of these things would need court orders and which are left to me. At least it didn’t take all day – in fact I was in and out in an hour. I even found street parking.
I went back to the bank. They accepted all my documents but said they can't give me the money directly; instead, in about three weeks their central processing department will issue a check "to the estate of Stephen J. Scherr." I will open an estate account, deposit this check into it, and then withdraw that money into my own account. This seems supremely pointless to me (why take a perfectly good bank account and put its contents on a paper check made out to the estate that already owned the account?). But I guess it creates a clearer paper trail for the IRS.
Even so it’s not very easy. To start, I went down to the bank where he had his checking account with the will and the death certificate, expecting them to transfer his funds to my account. Nope. Did you know that a person’s will is not the kind of legal document honored by a bank? I did not. Turns out the will is an expression of the deceased’s wish that I be the executor and beneficiary; it takes a court to establish that as a reality. The bank was not able to tell me exactly what documents they need, other than “court documents”; that was up to me to figure out.
With some online research I was able to determine that I needed a “letter testamentary,” and I also found instructions for how to do this without a lawyer. The actual experience down at the King County Superior Court was Brazil-like in its absurd bureaucracy: various documents with long names had to be filed and stamped and notarized and signed and copied, all in a very specific order, on two different floors of the courthouse, some with this clerk, some with that clerk, and some with the judge. There were specific associated rituals – for example, the clerk stamps these, but you stamp these yourself, using the clerk’s stamp. Why? Who knows. Stamp stamp. It all went pretty smoothly except that the will did not appear to some people to be original: it looked to them like a “very good Xerox.” I said it was original. They looked askance. I waited. The clerk ran her fingers over the signatures and said, “We’ll see what the judge says.” The judge looked at me over his glasses and said it looked like a copy. I said again that it was an original. He asked me if I had any siblings, or if my father had a life partner at the time of his death. I said no. He signed the order, and I took it back to the clerk, who said, “The judge accepted this will?” Yes he did. Thus I obtained my letter testamentary, stating that I am the executor. What about my being the sole beneficiary? Apparently that is not the court’s business – that’s just up to the executor, to dispose of the assets properly. I would never have been able to predict which of these things would need court orders and which are left to me. At least it didn’t take all day – in fact I was in and out in an hour. I even found street parking.
I went back to the bank. They accepted all my documents but said they can't give me the money directly; instead, in about three weeks their central processing department will issue a check "to the estate of Stephen J. Scherr." I will open an estate account, deposit this check into it, and then withdraw that money into my own account. This seems supremely pointless to me (why take a perfectly good bank account and put its contents on a paper check made out to the estate that already owned the account?). But I guess it creates a clearer paper trail for the IRS.
Case manager
While Dad lived with us I was not only his companion and primary caregiver much of the time, but also his case manager. This is a job I’ve never had before and good lord, what a job it is. I had no idea. For example, before he moved to Seattle, we had to get his insurance figured out. I heard from a friend that Kaiser Permanente, his HMO, had a strong reciprocal relationship with Group Health, a big HMO in Seattle. I learned all about this from scratch. I made all the calls to set him up as a “visiting member” of Group Health. I learned how long he could be a visiting member and what to do when his membership ran out. I collected brochures comparing benefit packages. Dad took care of having his records transferred, with the assistance of some fantastically helpful people at Kaiser.
In the first several days that Dad was in Seattle he and I had an extraordinary run of medical activities: we saw five different oncologists in three different hospital systems to consider a range of cancer therapies, scheduled a feeding tube insertion, scheduled an evaluation for an esophageal stent (which he did not get), obtained and administered new medications, and went to urgent care multiple times. And it continued from there. Early on, Dad and I did this together, but as he got sicker, it was mostly me. (Less often but crucially, Dale or Jes was in charge.) Over the ensuing weeks, every time we interacted with new medical personnel, someone had to explain exactly what was going on with Dad and what we were there for, then keep track of whatever information, recommendations, and prescriptions were generated by the visit. At home, there were medications and symptoms to track, so that we could report to his other caregivers. (Below is a picture of the whiteboard we used early on.) We were always trying out new things to make him more comfortable, like a heating pad, and a light switch he could operate easily even when he was very weak and confused, and a call button.

I’m saying these things in a long list because there were a lot of them, but in many cases just one of these things was quite taxing in and of itself. For example, the first time Dad was in the hospital, we were approached by a social worker who informed us that Dad now qualified for palliative care, meaning that nurses would come to our home instead of his having to schlep in for doctor visits. We gladly accepted, because his mobility was getting more limited. However, nothing happened after that. I didn’t know how to reach the person that had spoken with me at the hospital, so I did a bunch of online research and calls to customer service trying to figure out how to reach her, remembering only her first name and her general role. The situation was complicated by the fact that Group Health’s relationship with the hospital Dad was in was brand new (they used to partner with Virginia Mason, but had moved to Swedish just ten days before), so no one knew the systems yet. I finally got that person’s number and left a message - on Friday, and again on Monday - but she did not return my call. I made more calls to get the number for the palliative care office (not a number that is readily shared); when I eventually reached them, they told me that we would need a referral. They said the discharge papers from the hospital should have included that referral. I found our discharge papers, but there was no referral there. So I contacted Dad’s primary care provider and asked him to make the referral. He did so; palliative care called me back right away, and made the first home appointment. Whew. Almost everything required this kind of negotiation.
Dad felt lost a lot – disoriented in Seattle, because we were always driving around to some new place, and also confused by the complexity and uncertainty of his medical situation. He felt bad about being such an imposition on us, especially me; but he also trusted us completely, and recognized that he couldn’t do this on his own. Fortunately, I turned out to be an extremely good case manager, if I do say so myself. I learned everything, kept track of everything, and followed up on everything. I helped Dad negotiate difficult decisions. I knew what he needed and made sure his ever-changing lineup of medical personnel and administrators knew what he needed. I created systems to make his care more consistent and easier to coordinate among the different parties involved, like medication spreadsheets. Medical bureaucracy is very frustrating and I was relentlessly pleasant (thank you Sheryl Sandberg), except when I cried, hopefully at strategic moments in the negotiation.
In the first several days that Dad was in Seattle he and I had an extraordinary run of medical activities: we saw five different oncologists in three different hospital systems to consider a range of cancer therapies, scheduled a feeding tube insertion, scheduled an evaluation for an esophageal stent (which he did not get), obtained and administered new medications, and went to urgent care multiple times. And it continued from there. Early on, Dad and I did this together, but as he got sicker, it was mostly me. (Less often but crucially, Dale or Jes was in charge.) Over the ensuing weeks, every time we interacted with new medical personnel, someone had to explain exactly what was going on with Dad and what we were there for, then keep track of whatever information, recommendations, and prescriptions were generated by the visit. At home, there were medications and symptoms to track, so that we could report to his other caregivers. (Below is a picture of the whiteboard we used early on.) We were always trying out new things to make him more comfortable, like a heating pad, and a light switch he could operate easily even when he was very weak and confused, and a call button.
I’m saying these things in a long list because there were a lot of them, but in many cases just one of these things was quite taxing in and of itself. For example, the first time Dad was in the hospital, we were approached by a social worker who informed us that Dad now qualified for palliative care, meaning that nurses would come to our home instead of his having to schlep in for doctor visits. We gladly accepted, because his mobility was getting more limited. However, nothing happened after that. I didn’t know how to reach the person that had spoken with me at the hospital, so I did a bunch of online research and calls to customer service trying to figure out how to reach her, remembering only her first name and her general role. The situation was complicated by the fact that Group Health’s relationship with the hospital Dad was in was brand new (they used to partner with Virginia Mason, but had moved to Swedish just ten days before), so no one knew the systems yet. I finally got that person’s number and left a message - on Friday, and again on Monday - but she did not return my call. I made more calls to get the number for the palliative care office (not a number that is readily shared); when I eventually reached them, they told me that we would need a referral. They said the discharge papers from the hospital should have included that referral. I found our discharge papers, but there was no referral there. So I contacted Dad’s primary care provider and asked him to make the referral. He did so; palliative care called me back right away, and made the first home appointment. Whew. Almost everything required this kind of negotiation.
Dad felt lost a lot – disoriented in Seattle, because we were always driving around to some new place, and also confused by the complexity and uncertainty of his medical situation. He felt bad about being such an imposition on us, especially me; but he also trusted us completely, and recognized that he couldn’t do this on his own. Fortunately, I turned out to be an extremely good case manager, if I do say so myself. I learned everything, kept track of everything, and followed up on everything. I helped Dad negotiate difficult decisions. I knew what he needed and made sure his ever-changing lineup of medical personnel and administrators knew what he needed. I created systems to make his care more consistent and easier to coordinate among the different parties involved, like medication spreadsheets. Medical bureaucracy is very frustrating and I was relentlessly pleasant (thank you Sheryl Sandberg), except when I cried, hopefully at strategic moments in the negotiation.
When I’m dying, I want my help. :) Everybody got that?
It was a lot of work. But in our day and age, when medicine is a mosaic of specialties coordinated by a large business, this is a big part of what it means to take care of someone.
It was a lot of work. But in our day and age, when medicine is a mosaic of specialties coordinated by a large business, this is a big part of what it means to take care of someone.
Part of life
During Dad’s illness, people frequently asked us how the boys were doing. I think people were concerned that it would be very frightening for kids to be near someone who is dying. This was not our experience. There’s no question that it was sad, for them and for all of us, but it would have been sad no matter where Dad was.
Dale and I were open about our sadness. When I was overwhelmed by my emotions I just went ahead and cried. This made the boys nervous, especially Aaron; but it helped a lot when I explained what I like people to do when I am sad. I said I like people to just be with me, and not change the subject, and maybe give me a hug or a little pat. I said I didn’t want to be cheered up, because when I have big sad feelings I need to just feel them. I called it a “sad attack.” I explained that when I have a sad attack, I will cry for a little while, and then it will pass and I will feel okay again. Once I said what I wanted, both boys carried out my wishes to a T, which was very comforting for me (and I think helped them, too).
Sometimes Aaron was overwhelmed by sadness, and Jordan less frequently. How not? But after a streak of sadness they would go back to their normal selves. Their teachers, who all knew what was going on, reported that they were fine at school. When we talked to them about Dad’s condition we used nontechnical language, which was better for all of us. They were fascinated by all the science stuff, especially the IV nutrition, which was a complex daily medical ritual involving a lot of interesting gear. They were friendly with all the visiting nurses, and thanked them profusely for their care. When there was something going on that they didn’t want to be close to, they just went to their room and played together. They slept through the toughest stuff – Dad’s worst pain and waking nightmares were in the wee hours, and their room was far enough away that they were not disturbed. Their routines were disrupted because Dale and I were often busy taking care of Dad, and that was a drag for them. But they understood, and managed well enough.
Dad died in our home. Aaron did not want to see his body, which of course is perfectly fine. Jordan, however, wanted to say goodbye, so we sat together in Dad’s familiar bedroom, observing that his body was still and pale and peaceful. Jordan said, “It looks emptier.” After a few minutes, he was ready to leave.
It is easy for me to imagine circumstances that other families could be in that would be traumatizing, for the children and for everyone. In our case, we were sad together, because it is so sad that Grandpa is not with us anymore; but we were not traumatized. We knew we had taken the best care of him that any family possibly could take of their beloved grandpa. We gave him every kind of dignity we knew how to give. We could not keep the cancer away, and he died of it. It is a difficult truth that everything that lives, eventually dies. Our hope is for the kids to experience death as a part of life; heartbreaking, and also the inevitable end of every person’s story.
Coloring
Life with Dad involved many doctor appointments, regular trips to urgent care, and several days in the hospital. I was with him almost all the time. Fortunately, a perceptive friend had given me a beautiful grownup coloring book for my birthday, and this turned out to be the perfect way to while away all that medical downtime with my dad. It took just the tiniest bit of cognition, enough to occupy my mind but not enough to really require anything of me. It was a great conversation piece with all the doctors and nurses. And it engaged me in making something lovely.
Now I’m back to reading books, which I think is a sign that I have more cognition available. (When I tried to read in the hospital I just read the same sentence over and over.) But I really appreciated the coloring when I needed it.
Now I’m back to reading books, which I think is a sign that I have more cognition available. (When I tried to read in the hospital I just read the same sentence over and over.) But I really appreciated the coloring when I needed it.
Dad in March
In the seventh week, Dad finally had a feeding tube placed. However, feeding him through it didn’t work: his digestive system was not functioning enough to take the food. In the middle of that week he was overcome with pain unlike anything he had experienced before and went into the hospital. He had multiple dramatic events, including atrial fibrillation. The hospital did a few days of detective work to try and sort out what had caused the emergency pain, but didn’t find anything that they could treat. He was unconscious a lot, his pain was difficult to control, and when he was awake he was delirious, paranoid, and agitated.
In the eighth week, he again rallied from that low point. When we brought him home on Monday, March 7, he was lucid and comfortable: still very weak (barely ambulatory), but able to enjoy our company and the early signs of spring through the living room window. During the day we had precious conversations about what he wanted and did not want, medically. The nights, however, were very hard, with a lot of pain and waking nightmares.
After just a few days, he didn’t wake up anymore. He was at peace when he died, and I was with him.
In the eighth week, he again rallied from that low point. When we brought him home on Monday, March 7, he was lucid and comfortable: still very weak (barely ambulatory), but able to enjoy our company and the early signs of spring through the living room window. During the day we had precious conversations about what he wanted and did not want, medically. The nights, however, were very hard, with a lot of pain and waking nightmares.
After just a few days, he didn’t wake up anymore. He was at peace when he died, and I was with him.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


















