Monday, May 2, 2016

"Like all things, he embraced it with knowledge."

[Remarks at my father's memorial from his friend and colleague Michael Gaines. Listen here.]


I really need to seize this opportunity. Harris talked about our dinners, and it was a regular ritual. They tended to be bacchanal. We would drink and we would eat. Our last one was in December of last year. Steve picked me up in his cab -- we wouldn't drive our cars, we would only go by cab. I said "How you doing?" and he said, "Well, to be very frank," and he would be very frank, "I've lost some weight." I said, "Well, couldn't hurt!" I meant that in the nicest way. But it did look like he had lost quite a bit of weight. He said, "I really don't eat very well right now." I said "Steve, that's not like you." He said, "But tonight, we're going to be okay, and we're going to have a wonderful evening. I've been looking forward to it." And indeed we picked up Harris, we went, and Steve ordered, he would always order the same thing, everything would always be the same, including the orange wrapped in prosciutto, I don't know why he enjoyed that so much, he would always have that. He did order tonight, he could barely eat it, he ate half a petite filet, I remember this. He had hiccups. And then he said, "But I did want a drink." I said, "Well of course!" We had already had our share, but one more is certainly good for the road. He ordered his vodka martini -- He would never say, they would say "What kind of vodka, sir?" and he would say, "Vodka. Please." Very self-deprecating that way. He toasted, and he said: "I have hiccups. But I just turned 75 and I want to toast my good health." And that was ironic, because little did we know at the time. He said he had scheduled an endoscopy. I called a few days later, and said "When is that scheduled?" and he said "Well, I kind of moved it up. I moved it up because I'm feeling a little bit, I'm scuffled a little bit since the last time we met," which was just two days ago. I said "Well that's probably wise." And then of course he was diagnosed. 

We had two gatherings at Steve's house. Steve was very up front about what was happening to him. Like all things, he embraced it with knowledge and research. He was talking to us, and talking to us would help. Then he went up to Seattle with Rachel. And one of the finest things that I've done is make that trip, with Ben and Doug and Jim. It's funny, I was in trial at the time in Martinez, of all places, and I asked the judge, I said, "I've got a problem. I'd like to take a day off and go up to Seattle to visit friend who's ailing." And she said, "Couldn't you do it on a Friday?" After all, you get Fridays off, and this was Wednesday. And I said, "Yes. I could. There's really no reason I couldn't do that, and I would, if that's what you want. But there's this group of guys that I'd like to go with. It would be easier for me if I could do that, and I think our friend would enjoy it more." We got there, Steve was having a good day, it was a good day. The first forty-five minutes we sat around and he explained to us his course of treatment, what he was going through, with his hands flying in the air as he does. And then we got to talk. Ben was asking questions - Ben is very ebullient. Jim was just stunned. We were quiet. Then we started to talk about cases, cases that we had done together. I told the story of our death penalty trial in Redwood City, we were representing a young man who was accused of killing a police officer from East Palo Alto. We were coming upon a penalty phase, and I had written out this penalty phase argument. I said "Steve, I always like to keep you in the loop, and I'd like you to listen." And this was at his house, and I read it to him, and about an hour and a half later he said, "Oh, don't do that." I said, "Okay, there seems to be a problem," and he said, "Let me modify it a little bit." I'm writing, writing, word for word, leaving nothing to chance, the whole thing was changed, turned on its ear, and we ended up saving the young man's life. It was great. When the argument was over, he looked at me and he said, "Michael, that's the best I've ever heard." [laughter]

We played tennis every Saturday at Washington High. Rachel and Matthew, my older son, we would go to the Lucky Penny on weekends, which is the Copper Penny now. Not great meals, but nonetheless that's what we did, because we were cheap and we loved to eat, we really did. 

One of the most remarkable weddings that I've ever been to in my life was in Portland, with Rachel and Dale, and of course we went up with Doug and Freya and Betsy. It's funny, because Steve was attending to the wedding party, as he should be. And Ben, my god, the events that we had - Steve would say "Are you guys enjoying yourselves?" and we would say "Yes we are, we're doing rather well!" [laughter] He had no idea what was going on but it is still one of the most wonderful life cycle events that I've ever been to. We had so much fun.*

And here's something else: This is - I don't want anyone to take this the wrong way. I had a time in my life when I thought I was going to be married. I thought I was going to get married, and I was committed to getting married. Apparently I proposed, apparently she said yes, plans had been made, venues, that kind of thing. Deep into it. I realized that at night I was waking up with anxiety, I was having dreams, Betsy I had gotten to know, she was a friend, but I had taken a shine to her from afar, already. I just felt like this relationship, I cannot, I can't do this. She was living out in the Richmond district at that time, not too far from Steve. I remember, I had my key, her key, and I was going to go do this thing. Terrifying. But I had to do it. I walked in I said "Listen. I don't want you to take this the wrong way. There is something that I need to, um, I need to cancel. Is that the right word? I need to put an end to this and I'm awfully sorry." She was very hurt. Often we're on the wrong side of these things. I didn't mean any harm. It was self-preservation. I must say that when I got out the door, even though I rained some terrible hurt on somebody, I did have wings on my heels. I felt better. And I said, wait a minute! Where am I going to go right now? Footloose and fancy free. And it was just one of those things, I said "I've got ten blocks and I know exactly where I'm going," and I went banging on Steve's door, and I said listen, I've just been through this thing. He said, "A scotch?" I knew exactly where he kept it, out it came, and the peanuts, always the peanuts. Steve did try to make a chess player of me, he would do that. I was just awful. He would always say, "Well you will recall, the last time we did this, and you will recall." It was just a night that I remember. I felt like I saved my life, and I shared it with a friend, someone that I knew was my neighbor for 42 years.

When I think about it, the first person that I know of that was a lawyer I met when I was twelve, that was Marty Lurie. And I think the second person was Steve Scherr, when I was out here. I felt like I'd known him forever. Again, this trip up to Seattle was one of the greatest things that I've ever done - things I'm most thankful for. And this has taken me aback. It really has. It's remarkable what a nice human being. I'll miss him.


* A dozen or so of my dad's friends came to Portland for our wedding, in 1993. It was also Ben Winslow's birthday, probably a significant birthday, and apparently they had a very good time. All of them refer to this the way Michael did here - mysteriously, and with an awe and a reverie that goes way beyond anything that could possibly be occasioned by the wedding itself. No one ever reveals the nature of the good time. And I am sure I do not want to know!

Saturday, April 30, 2016

"Steve beat me about two thousand times more than I beat Steve."

[Remarks at my father's memorial from his friend and chess partner Bob Berman. Listen here.]


My name is Bob Berman. I remember very well when my friendship with Steve really began. I started trying to earn a living down in the Hall of Justice in 1973 or 1974, and I became acquainted with Steve as just one of the wonderful cast of characters that worked down there. But we weren't especially friendly. In 1975 I took a job at the public defender's office, and one afternoon that year I was at my desk, which was just one of many desks in this large ugly room. And Steve walked in. He was obviously done with whatever he had to do that day and was just looking for someone to have a talk with. So we started talking and at one point he innocently said, "Do you play chess?" I said "Well, as a matter of fact I do."

That was the beginning of a beautiful friendship. Within a week we had started a routine, because everything with Steve ends up as a routine. On Wednesday nights I would go to Steve's apartment; he and Jean would normally have an early dinner; I'd show up after their dinner, and Steve and I would play chess. For hours. Probably for about four hours. And we would play a lot of games, because we would agree the week before what opening we were going to play. So we weren't just playing chess, we were of course learning: learning the openings and learning the variations. And this won't be surprising for me to tell you that Steve was a much better chess player than I was. I don't know if he had a superior intuitive grasp of the game, but he had two very important advantages. One, he was smarter than I was, and when you play chess, there's not a lot of luck involved, so if you are smarter than your opponent then you're going to do well. The other advantage, which was more amazing to me, is he had this incredible memory of chess games we had played - as the years went on, chess games we had played years ago, and positions we were in. Steve would never make the same mistake twice. I would fall into the same stupid opening traps over and over again -- "Oh, I'm in fried liver," you can imagine what being in fried liver is. We would be in the middle of a game, maybe twenty moves in, and I would make a move, and Steve would say, "No Bob, a couple of years ago you tried that move." And he never complained; that's all he'd say; but what he was saying was, "It didn't work two years ago, it's not going to work now."

I rarely -- and we played for forty years, played a lot in those early years, when I moved away from San Francisco we didn't play as often but we still played -- and I rarely beat Steve at chess. That's not to say I always lost; we played to a lot of draws. For Steve a draw I think was just a draw; for me it was a tremendous victory. But if I had to estimate how many times Steve beat me, as opposed to me beating Steve, I would say a conservative estimate is that Steve beat me at least two thousand times more than I beat Steve. And when you're playing a competitive game and you're losing two thousand times more often than your opponent, you have to be able to do this without letting it bother you. And it was okay, I kind of expected it, and for the first twenty years it didn't really bother me. And then twenty years ago Jane and I got together. And every day after I had played chess with Steve the night before, Jane would say, "Oh Bob, how did you do at chess last night?" Well except on those rare occasions when I actually did well, I would mumble, "I did fine." I hated that question.

Well, as the years went on, our lives changed, sometimes tragically, sometimes just in the way things change, but our friendship only grew. When Jean died, Steve and I would start going out to dinner on Wednesday nights; we'd go for an early dinner, and then we'd go back to his apartment and play a couple games of chess. We took turns choosing the restaurants. I could choose any restaurant I wanted, but Steve was a meat-and-potatoes man, he didn't want anything exotic or anything new. So my choice was somewhat limited. I chose a lot of Italian restaurants. When it was Steve's turn, he would usually choose the Pacific Cafe. I think he was very fond of their butter. And at some point, let's say just about the dinners, I still loved playing chess, but chess is a very quiet sport, you don't really talk to people. But at these dinners we would talk. And as you've heard from other people, Steve loved theater, and he loved movies; so do I, and we would talk about those things, we'd talk about books, and we'd talk about science, and the conversations were wonderful, I just had to be careful never to make an overgeneralization, or I would be suddenly attacked. But I learned that, and those dinners were really fun.

After a while we started going to plays together once in a while in San Francisco, and Berkeley, and that added to our friendship. And then a number of years ago, Steve started coming up to Ashland every year, with Jane and with me, and we'd go to seven, eight plays. The three of us we'd all have seats together, we'd go out to dinner a number of times during that week. That was a great experience and just added to our friendship. It seems like everything we did added to our friendship. And I'm going to miss Steve very much. He was a very important friend to me and a wonderful man.

But Jane, in answer to your question, how did I do at chess with Steve? ... I did great.

Tuesday, April 26, 2016

"You should not hate your adversary."

[Remarks at my father's memorial from his friend and colleague Harris Taback. Listen here.]


Hello everybody. I'm Harris Taback. The reason I was asked to speak here today, I'm speaking on behalf of the Criminal Trial Lawyers Association of Northern California. I am a former president of that organization, probably about four years ago I finished my two-year term. The organization started well over fifty years ago, and it started as, and continues to be, an organization that is a community of criminal defense lawyers. We would put on events, we would support each other, it was a place to have lunch, to hear a speaker, and to be part of a community. When I took over as president, I put on, over two years, probably ten or so events. Steve Scherr, who had been a buddy of mine now for a long time, long retired, came to every one of those events. He didn't miss one. He was the first guy to respond "I'll be there," send in his check. He just loved being part of the community.

But he wasn't just a part of it, and you all know this, but to family members and friends outside our community, you gotta know it's not enough to say that he was a great criminal defense lawyer, that he was magnificent at trial. I don't think there was a lawyer, let alone prosecutor or defense attorney, in the Hall of Justice, practicing at 850 Bryant Street, that was more respected by his peers; that was more respected by the judiciary. If you were having breakfast with Steve Scherr at the cafeteria at 850 Bryant, the guy couldn't swallow a bite of food without lawyers running up to him, with motions, showing him police reports, asking "What do you think? What do you think?" And he had time, he cared, to answer all of these questions.

The thing about Steve, and Jim pointed out, there was no ego involved. It wasn't like you were coming up to him and he just loved that kind of attention. But when you talked to Steve with your issue, it was equally important to know that you, also, could not have an ego. Because if you had an ego, it was going to get hurt. Honest. Brutal. There were times when I just wanted to give him my bar card, like what am I doing practicing law. He would ask questions, I would ask him for advice and he'd ask me these detailed questions, and I would say, "Well, who knows?" and he would look at me and he would say, "Well, I would hope your client's lawyer does!"

We would talk, we would talk it out. I was doing a trial in Lakeport, an attempted murder case where my client shot several rounds of a shotgun, several shells through a closed door and almost killed the individual on the other side of the door, and but for emergency surgery the person would have died. So we had a defense, a heat-of-passion defense. I had forensic psychiatric work done on the client. I was a much younger lawyer at the time. Steve agreed to have lunch with me before I drove up to begin the trial, and I thought it was going to be a quick lunch. So we sit down, and I start asking him some questions about my direct examination, which you would think is simple enough, to just ask a doctor some questions: "What did you do," and "What did you read," and "What are you considering," so different than cross. I started running some ideas by Steve, and that lunch turned out to be about three and a half hours, where Steve was like, "Okay. And no. And this is how you do it." We sat down and wrote the questions out, as Jim was talking about, question by question. I just can't tell you what it felt like to have that type of wisdom shared with you by a guy who could not have been more generous. And it worked; we beat the attempted murder charge; the direct examination that he prepped me for I think helped tremendously.

I'm not the only lawyer that would come up here and tell stories about how he mentored them. I am kind of convinced that in thirty-five years of practicing the guy never picked up a check in San Francisco at lunch. Because we were always paying him essentially for his meal.

So the question becomes that I have, is, what does he leave us with? How do we process this loss? I'll tell you, Michael Gaines and I would have dinners with Steve Scherr at Alfred's Steak House, probably four times a year for many many years now. We know Steve's love of literature, we would talk books, Michael and Steve would talk books I've never heard of. I'd sit and listen to these book reports that these guys were doing. Movies. Music. We've heard of his love for the Dead, and Baez, Steve loved Bob Dylan as well, and he could talk about all those subjects for hours with great knowledge. But this was the guy who once taught me the greatest lesson. My takeaway from Steve and my relationship with him. He was taking me to a Warriors game in the 90s, picked me up, driving to the Oakland Coliseum, and we're talking about this trial that we had coming up, we had co-defendants. And at a certain point you know, this young lawyer, I was coming from a much more radicalized position than Steve, sort of the Abbie Hoffman school of thought. And I'd say to Steve, "I hate prosecutors. I hate 'em." And he looked at me like I was out of my mind, like, "What are you talking about? What do you mean, you hate prosecutors?" I said, "Well how could anybody, how could you charge someone with a crime and stand up there and try to put them in jail, anyone who can do that, you know." And he gives me this civics lesson. About how people need to do that! There needs to be a social system in place, there are people that have to take on a job of being a prosecutor. That doesn't mean they're a bad person. You should not hate your adversary.

And that lesson in civility is something that came to me the other night, preparing for a hearing on Friday. To stay civil, as I was tossing and turning. Not to go in and wrestle. You're the face of your client, you gotta be the face of reason. Take the higher moral ground. And I won't forget the lesson of civility: but I also won't forget his dedication to what he spent his adult life doing, which is standing up for those of us who are weak, those of us who have been accused by the power of the state, demanding that justice be served, that the proceeding be fair, that the defense be competent. I'll tell you, one of his clients is here today. She doesn't know many of you. But I ran into her years ago at a concert, and we started chatting it up, and she said what do you do, and I said, "I'm a defense lawyer in San Francisco." She goes "Really! Do you know Jim Collins and Steve Scherr?" I go "Indeed I do." She says, "Well let me tell you something. Those two guys saved my life." Now I have permission, I asked her if it was okay to talk about this, and she said of course. She was a doctor who was charged with murder for how the prosecution thought she handled a child making end-of-life decisions. She said that Jim and Steve could not have been kinder, could not have been more sympathetic, and could not have been there more for her. And of course the two of them put together, a brilliant, brilliant defense. She was not charged; she was allowed to continue practicing, she was able to go on with her life. But she's not forgotten what Steve Scherr has done for her. Jim always would say that Steve is the brains, and that Steve was [laughter]. But Steve would say, Steve always would say that that is not true. That Jim is by far among the smartest guys in the room, don't ever forget that.

Steve's fight for justice, for fairness, for the underdog... I'm figuring as I'm going to close my remarks, how do I tie it together with his love of literature, film, and music. And I thought of John Steinbeck's The Grapes of Wrath, which is an amazing novel, it was turned into an amazing film, and Woody Guthrie, one of Bob Dylan's heroes, wrote an amazing song, The Ballad of Tom Joad. Now Tom Joad was radicalized by the Dust Bowl, and his family's treatment by the powers that be. They were forced to California, where they did not find any welcoming hand, and justice was hard to come by. Tom Joad wound up killing a deputy who had killed Tom Joad's friend, Preacher Casey, who was standing up for the working man, standing up for those among us who needed help and protection. And after Tom Joad killed that deputy he knew his time with his family in this world was over. Tom Joad was leaving his family for good, as he had to skedaddle out of town to beat the deputies on his heels. But he had to say goodbye. Before he left, he went that night to the camp, and he found his mother sleeping, and he went to kiss her gently on the head, to say goodbye. And Woody Guthrie wrote these words, and this is what I'm going to leave you with.

Tom Joad run back where his mother was asleep
He woke her up out of bed
And he kissed goodbye to the mother that he loved
And he said what Preacher Casey said, Tom Joad,
He said what Preacher Casey said.

Everybody might just be one big soul
Well it looks that way to me.
Everywhere that we love, in the day or night,
That's where I'm going to be, Ma.
That's where I'm going to be.

Wherever little children are hungry and crying,
Wherever people ain't free;
Wherever men are fightin' for their rights
That's where I'm going to be, Ma,
That's where I'm going to be.

So I say to all of you, in all those troubles, in all the cases we will continue to do and defend our clients, where people are fighting; just look, and that's where Steve Scherr will be.

Monday, April 25, 2016

"It was like eating lunch with Socrates."

[Remarks at my father's memorial from his friend and colleague Ben Winslow, who practiced law with him for decades. Listen here.]



My name is Ben Winslow, and I worked with Jim and Steve for many many years. When I first met Steve forty years ago, Doug Schmidt brought him to our office and said, this guy wants to rent an office from us. This skinny guy, curly hair, horn-rimmed glasses. He had one corduroy suit that was wrinkled, we all had one suit in those days, many of them like Steve's, and Steve moved in. Webster Street is like a big family. It's an old house: Steve had an office in one of the bedrooms, Jim was in another bedroom, Doug Schmidt was in the dining room, I was in the front room, and this went on for thirty or forty years.

Steve was a mathematician and liked physics, so the other day I was thinking, what could I do mathematical. So I thought well if I had lunch with Steve twice a week for forty years, how many lunches would that be, and I know it's more than twice a week but if I claim more than that Steve if he were here would question my methodology and want to know how I got to two times or three times or four times a week. But it's something like four thousand lunches. And I don't know if you remember that Billy Crystal play "Seven Hundred Sundays" where he talked about the number of Sundays he spent with his father while he was alive; well Jim and I and Doug had four thousand lunches with Steve. That's four thousand discussions, four thousand arguments, four thousand "How do you get that?" We used to say it was like eating lunch with Socrates.

He had this rigorous intellectual thing that he did with you. Even like Josh who's here today, Josh sits in Steve's room now, if you had a trial or something you would go in and talk to Steve about it and you'd be in there for an hour and a half. You'd go in thinking you had a great case and you'd leave thinking you were going to get killed and never get the evidence in and you might as well give up. But by the time you got to trial you'd be glad you went through that because it'd be a rigorous thing, you'd have to support your ideas and your thoughts, it would make you better.

So four thousand lunches. It reminded me, Steve was always fighting his weight. In the early days he was skinny, and then he got heavier and heavier and he wanted to lose some weight. Jim was talking about the pictures in his desk, he had another morning ritual He walked in every morning, he had a paper towel, and he centered it on his desk, and then he placed two glazed donuts on the paper. Pulled out the coffee, took off the top, and then he would eat the two glazed donuts and drink the coffee. I've always been a fit guy and I would walk through and say "Steve, it's going to be hard to lose weight with those two glazed donuts." And after about three months he said, "Maybe I'll cut down to one." And later he did lose a lot of weight.

We had a million conversations with Steve and what I remember most about Steve is that he was a big believer in certain things, and one of the things that he always talked about, he believed everybody's right to practice their religion, but he believed in the separation of church and state. He was a big supporter of the American Civil Liberties Union. A great Woody Allen quote, Steve liked Woody Allen a lot, Woody Allen said, "To you I am an atheist; to God I am the loyal opposition." Steve was the loyal opposition.

He loved to travel. The whole office when Maura got married we all went to Peru, she set up this great trip and we all went to Peru, Jean and Steve went to Peru, told me I think it was one of the great trips of his life. It was a lot of fun - went to Macchu Picchu, the valley of the Incas, had a great, great time. I know his trips with the family to Africa, when he took the grandchildren, he loved those trips, he would plan them out meticulously. Steve was very anal and liked orderly things, and I'm exactly like Steve, so we got along really well. We both line up our money by denominations, all facing the same way, and we took a lot of guff over the years for that. The only thing we didn't do was put it by serial number, that would really be sick.

Steve was a Deadhead, he loved the Grateful Dead. When you work with somebody for forty years, I remember when Rachel was young one weekend he came in one Friday, I said "what's up for the weekend," and he said "Oh, Rachel is going to go somebody's house tonight and kick back with Jack." I said, "Kick back with Jack? Steve, what do you think that means?" He said, "She probably has a friend named Jack." I said "No, they're going to drink a lot of Jack Daniels." He goes "Oh my God!" Rachel, remember this story? [Me out in the audience: "I was so grounded."] Yeah, I busted you.

When Rachel was going to go to high school, Steve got really involved in whether she should go to Washington or Lowell. He was very interested in her education and a very loving and caring father as Jim has already described. He investigated everything, and Rachel went on and did great.

Steve is a mentor to many people. I can't tell you the number of young people who came through the office, talk to him about cases, he always had time for people. They probably spent about three times as long in there as they thought they were going to be in there, but he was very happy to do that. Steve also, as was alluded to earlier, I don't think a lot of people know this about him but you know Steve spent two years in the military. He was very proud of his army service. Rachel tells me he had a great service at the National Cemetery where he's buried, had a bugler, they fired a volley, I think he would have been very proud of that, he was very proud of his service. But at the same time, Steve was patriotic, but when he didn't agree with something, he didn't agree with it. I think that's, a very loyal American but he would state his opinion in a great way.

The final thing I just wanted to say is that Rachel called Jim and I when Steve wasn't doing well and Jim, myself, Michael Gaines and Doug Schmidt went up to visit Steve, we flew up for the day and stayed and then came back, and I think Tito and Steve Eckdish had been up there for many days before. I've always been Steve's lawyer, so when this all happened to Steve and was very sudden, Steve did a lot of talking with me and made a lot of plans and I went to see him. I think when you go through life you learn certain lessons from people, you know when you're a kid you want to play sports, you see somebody play baseball and that's how you want to play baseball. When you're a young lawyer you go watch a trial to see somebody be good in trial that's how you know how to do a trial. When I saw Steve go through this, and how he did with the grace and dignity and class that he did it with, I thought to myself, I just hope that I will be half the person that he was the way he went through all this. How he did it, and how he was concerned about everybody, how they were doing, how they were feeling, how Rachel was doing, and his grandchildren. It's pretty amazing to watch how elegant he was about it and dignified. It was an amazing thing for me, I learned a lot just watching him.

Steve probably didn't believe in heaven. But if he goes there, and maybe he has, he's probably sitting there with Socrates right now having an argument.

Sunday, April 24, 2016

"Steve never, that I can remember, got mad."

[Remarks at my father's memorial from his friend and colleague Jim Collins, who practiced law with him for decades. Listen here.]


Good afternoon. I'm Jim Collins; I'm one of the lawyers from Webster Street, and I've known Steve thirty years or more, practiced law together. One of the things about Steve that I have told an awful lot of people, but I would never dare tell him, was he may be the smartest person I have ever met. The last thing you'd want to do is tell him that. The fact is you could talk to Steve about all kinds of things. All the lawyers here who practice criminal law know how smart he was when it came to the practice of criminal law. But you could talk to Steve about books, about movies, about sports. You could talk to him about history. You didn't really want to talk to him about politics, but you could. He was knowledgeable, so knowledgeable on all those subjects, it was amazing.

The fact is, one of his characteristics that stands out to me, is Steve never, that I can remember, got mad. Might get agitated; I'll get to that in a second. But he never got mad. He was always calm; he was always thoughtful. The agitation, though, was something that some of us at the office could create. For instance, Steve, hard to believe, hated, really couldn't stand looking at really horrible crime scene pictures of bodies, just ghastly photographs, he hated looking at them. You would think that's crazy, conisdering how many murder cases he did, how many he second-chaired for Doug Schmidt, myself, Michael Gaines. Hated them. So what Schmidt and I and Winslow would do periodically is Steve had a ritual. When he came into the office in the morning, when he got into his office, he would open his middle drawer, and he'd put his wallet in there and close it. Then when he'd go to lunch, he would always go to the bathroom, and then wash his hands and come out, and get the wallet out of the middle drawer. Well once in a while, we would pick some of the most ghastly pictures you ever saw, and once he went to the bathroom, we'd sneak into his office, open the door, and put it right on top of the wallet. Then we'd go into my office, and we'd pretend like I'm talking business, and when he'd come out of the bathroom, "Come on Steve, we're going to lunch." Well he'd go into his office, he'd open, and you would hear something. It would be an "Anh!" or some sort of noise like "Oh my god." And we would start laughing like kids in high school. And that's really what we were. Steve would come in and he was agitated and he would see us laughing and he'd say, "Winslow," or Schmidt, Collins, and then he'd start laughing.

The times at Webster Street - The other thing you could do to Steve, I have to tell you this. Those of you who know Steve, his desk had to be perfect. Everything had to be absolutely straight. You couldn't move. So what you would do, when you were talking to him his computer was to the left. When he'd turn away you'd just move his books just a bit. And he'd turn back and he'd look at it, and he'd straighten it. I got to three times before he realized I did it. And he'd get agitated and he would laugh. We had an awful lot of those laughs at Webster Street. We had a great time over at Webster Street.

One of the things about Steve is he was really wonderful to work with on a serious trial. Unlike most criminal lawyers, and I include all of you here, he really didn't have a big ego involved in the trial of the case. He could sit there with you and not really want to get up there and do the cross because he could do it better, like probably most of us would. He was really wonderful to work with because he was always calm, always thoughtful, he always, I like maybe many of you when questions would come out from the jury it was oh my god, I've lost. And he would be, "You don't know what they're thinking." He was always calm. A great example, we were trying a case, and it was an insanity defense, and we're putting on a psychiatrist, guy had great credentials, he was the head of the school of psychiatry at Langley Porter [the psychiatric hospital at UCSF]. And he was on our side. These amazing credentials, but he had never ever testified in court. And so we had him prepared, and we go in there very nervous, and I start questioning him, and all of a sudden I'm realizing, "Boy this guy is really good. He's really good." and I look down and Steve's written a big note: "He's great! Keep him talking!" So I keep going, and I realize, I'm done. I lean down to Steve after a moment and I say "I got nothing else" and he says "Keep him talking" and I say "What am I going to say?" So he says, he gives me a question, as I stand up to ask the question, he starts writing in big print, questions for me to go, and for the next fifteen or twenty minutes, the ventriloquist wrote the questions, the dummy asked them, and it worked perfectly. And that was a perfect example of working with Steve. Because the witness was great; I was good; but all because of the brains of Steve, sitting there, without that ego and willing to work with you. He was just wonderful to work with.

You could go on telling Webster Street stories and talking about the law and Steve, because we all know how smart he was. But you know, to me what's more important is somebody, especially when we come to the end, it's not how good a lawyer you are. It's what kind of a person you are. And those of you who know Steve know, he cared about people. He really cared about people. He cared about his friends. He loved his sister Judith. He loved Jean, who left us way too soon, and he adored and was so proud and so proud and so loved Rachel. And the last few years Dale and the two grandsons. It was just wonderful. And to me as I say at the end it's not really about whether you're a good lawyer or not, it's what kind of person you are, and to me, to me, Steve Scherr was a really wonderful, good human being, and to me that's the highest compliment I could pay anybody. And I'm going to miss him.

"Steve was our Siri."

[Remarks at my father's memorial from his cousin Marcia, who still lives in Baltimore. Listen here.]


The last time I saw Steve was in the spring of last year, when we gathered together to remember our aunt E.T., who had passed away in January of 2015. He reminded me then that I now was the matriarch of our family, like I had to know. Little did I imagine at that time that I would be attending his memorial so soon after. I knew Steve before he was born, when his mother, my aunt Esther, was pregnant. Born in DC, he lived in Parkchester, New York as a young child with Esther and his dad Eddie. They moved to Takoma Park, Maryland, where Judith joined the family. As a baby we called Steve "Porky," because his hair always stood straight up in the air like a porcupine. He was always very precocious, and we never knew what would come out of his mouth. His mom used to tell us this story, that when she first visited him at an open house in kindergarten, he introduced his teacher as, "This is the lady I told you looks just like a mouse." Years later, when the family moved to Baltimore, the Scherrs lived not far from our family and we spent a lot of time together. Steve was always brilliant, but not the easiest of teenagers. He won a National Merit Scholarship at Johns Hopkins University, but preferred playing pool or bridge to attending classes. He left Hopkins, worked at Bethlehem Steel for a while, returned to Hopkins for a while, and then enlisted in the army. He thought this would be a good opportunity for him to travel and to see the world. But this was not to be. After taking an aptitude test, he scored so high that he was placed in army intelligence. Much to his disappointment, he remained at Fort Holabird [in Baltimore] as an instructor his entire time in the service. It was here that he first whet his appetite for studying law as a career. Most of you here today know where that interest took him, and how well he succeeded in his field here in San Francisco. And to the family back in Baltimore, Steve was our Siri. If E.T. or I had a question about movies, literature, just about anything, we'd call him and get the answer immediately. He was very especially close to my sister Linda. She was the only cousin she invited to her sweet sixteen party, and through the years they remained best of friends. When he visited us in recent years in Baltimore, he would stay with Linda and watch old movies until all hours. Linda is so sorry she was unable to be here today, she deeply misses Steve. There are so many, many things I could say about this special man - his intellect, his wit, his humor - but most of you are already aware of them. The one thing that stands out so much for me was his love and devotion to his family: his wife Jean, his daughter Rachel, son-in-law Dale, grandsons Jordan and Aaron, sister Judith and her wife Deena, his mom Esther and his dad Eddie. As a child and a young man he gave his mother a rough time, but in later years he showed her such love and admiration it brought much unexpected joy to her life. It's hard for me to think of Steve in the past tense. He will always be alive in my heart.

Thursday, April 14, 2016

"Early on, I imagined I would pay him back."

[Dale's eulogy to Dad, as read at the SF memorial.]

So I’m the guy in the room who knew Steve as a father-in-law. And what a tremendous father-in-law he was!

I was a nervous wreck when I first came to San Francisco in 1989. I had driven down from my parent’s small farm in Idaho to visit Rachel in her city. Back in the early years, Steve could certainly make a green college student nervous. If he had you under cross-examination for poorly supported opinions and shoddy knowledge of the facts—well, look out. Steve always knew the facts.

Despite his gravitas and stentorian voice, he was a softie of a father-in-law. When I married Rachel four years later, I had dropped out of college and was working nightshift as a veterinary technician. These were not ideal husband-of-beloved-daughter credentials. But Steve threw us a great party in Portland and made a fine toast. He was always happy to have me in the family.

I can’t begin to count how many meals Steve paid for since I first came to San Francisco. He bought airline tickets so we could attend Alan’s seders, sent checks to me during some of the destitute undergraduate years, bankrolled family trips to Yellowstone National Park, to Hawaii, to Tanzania, to Arizona. Early on, I imagined I would pay him back. But he was certainly never going to let me write him a check.

The dollars I can tally up. What is really impossible to measure is how much fun and spirit Steve brought to the table. He sang with wild abandon when the mood struck him: a little Johnny Cash or Beatles rolling down some highway with my boys. Grateful Dead or Joan Baez back in the San Francisco apartment. Sometimes he topped it off with ridiculous dancing with his wife Jean. Steve, you had a voice for the courtroom—not so much for singing. But you never let that get in the way of having a good time.

And as far as I know, Steve never let anything get in the way of being himself. He was the same Steve whether in a tuxedo at a wedding, a suit in the courtroom, or his sweats on the couch. In a lot full of plush lawyer cars, he had the dinged-up 1994 Camry with the busted mirror and scraped door. He always needed a better reason to do something than just because someone told him to. Let's take, for example, getting dressed. You probably don’t know this: Steve put his shoes on first, then his pants, always. It’s more comfortable to tie your shoes before your pants are on, and once your pants are on, you’re ready to go. Of course.

He had his habits. I’m pretty sure he read every single San Francisco Chronicle that landed on the steps to his apartment. And we all knew if we wanted to change his habits, we needed a damn good reason and plenty of time for arguments and cross-examination. Even then the odds were really long. In the 25 years I visited him in San Francisco, there was always Canada Dry Ginger Ale and Velveeta in the refrigerator. The butter was in the same container. The knives were impossible to cut with, the M&M’s, whiskey, and vodka were in the same cabinet. He never rushed to change. Some of the things in his apartment could have used updating, but the constancy of 1710 Cabrillo Street was reassuring.

And what was most immutable of all was his love and support. He loved his city. He loved his people. He loved his family. Everyone said they could count on Steve. He was such a rock in the river.

When Steve was living with us in Seattle early this year, Rachel invited people to write him a toast, and we read those to him. It was really a sweet time for him, for Rachel and I, and for our boys. (And let me just say he cherished those toasts.) I want to finish with words from one of those toasts. Alicia Walker and Rachel were neighborhood kids together in the Richmond in the 1970s. Alicia’s letter was one of the last things we read together. So, from Alicia to Steve:
“ I have a memory of you and Rachel that I cannot quite place in time. We had been at some event that involved balloons, and as we left, you and Rachel were walking in front of me holding hands and a balloon and then you turned to one another, said something I couldn't hear, and then let the balloon go. You both had a look of absolute delight on your faces as you watched it fly away, and were so absolutely content in each others' company. It was a really a lovely sight. As I get older, I realize how very rare those simple moments of complete comfort in another person's presence are, and how being able to have that connection with another person is really among the greatest accomplishments in life.”
Indeed. Steve Scherr connected with so many of us. We were so lucky to share our time with him, and we will always love and cherish him, and keep his joyfulness in our hearts.